Shelby was a member of the National Honor Society. She was a member of the All-Academic All-State golf team, a member of the Southeastern Conference All-Academic team, and she was also a Southeastern Conference scholar athlete for golf. Shelby was a four-year member of the girls varsity soccer team. She was voted captain of the soccer team in both her junior and senior years. In addition to being on the soccer team. Shelby was also a member of the cross-country and JV basketball teams her sophomore year, and a member of the golf team for her junior and senior years.
Shelby will be attending Xavier University in the fall to pursue an accountancy degree.